Ok so this is my take on the fight, i watched and judged as objectively as i could, i have 3 rounds different to you Mex, rounds 2, 4 and 11 i had for Floyd and you had them for Castillo. Considering this was Floyd's first fight at 135 and it was against a champion in Castillo i think he did well and clearly won imo. I would love for everyone to tell me why they disagree with my take on any round and discuss their difference in opinion. Round 1, Easy Floyd round, dominated the first minute. 10-9 Floyd. Round 2, Clear Floyd round, landed the more significant shots, ref called a slip on a knockdown so really should have been a 10-8 round for Floyd. 10-9 Floyd. 20-18 Floyd Round 3, Another Floyd round, won it with the jab. 10-9 Floyd. 30-27 Floyd. Round 4, Close round but Castillo missing more than landing so i give it to Floyd. 10-9 Floyd. 40-36 Floyd. Round 5, Better round for Jose but Floyd lands some very nice hard shots while Castillo is still missing with most of his shots. 10-9 Floyd. 50-45 Floyd. Round 6, Close round, Jose wins it with body shots. 10-9 Castillo. 59-55 Floyd. Round 7, Dominant round by Castillo and easily his best round of the fight so far. 10-9 Castillo. 68-65 Floyd. Round 8, Another Castillo round, Floyd not throwing enough and just defending, Castillo loses a point for not breaking when ref says so, had been warned multiple times. 9-9 Even round. 77-74 Floyd. Round 9, Clear Castillo round, throwing and landing too much and keeping Floyd on the back foot. 10-9 Castillo. 86-84 Floyd. Round 10, Finally Floyd comes back and wins his first round since the 5th but has a point deducted for pushing. 9-9 Even round. 95-93 Floyd. Round 11, Very even round that could have gone either way, great inside fighting by both but more so by Floyd so i give the round to him just. 10-9 Floyd. 105-102 Floyd. Round 12, Castillo wins the last round, again on activity. 10-9 Castillo. 114-112 Floyd. So i had 6 rounds for Floyd, 4 rounds for Jose and 2 even rounds, at worst it could have been a draw but not a loss for Floyd imo and that missed knockdown also would have made Floyd win more clearly if it had been correctly called.